7 Best Tequilas for Margarita Mix
Published: April 2025
Let's cut to the chase—a killer margarita isn't just about the mix. The tequila you pour matters just as much as what you're pouring it into. And since our Batchwell mixes are crafted with real ingredients and zero B.S., you'll want a tequila that can keep up.
Whether you're shaking up our Classic Margarita Singles or bringing the heat with our Spicy Margarita Singles, we've done the "research" (tough job, we know) to match you with tequilas worthy of your next pour.
Why Your Tequila Choice Actually Matters
Here's the deal: good tequila + good mix = great margarita. It's not rocket science.
Our pocket-sized craft packets are designed to let quality ingredients shine through, not mask cheap booze. That means the tequila you choose will either elevate your margarita game or drag it down faster than that one friend who insists on doing karaoke after three drinks.
A few non-negotiables before we dive in:
- Always go 100% blue agave. Anything else is basically a hangover in a bottle.
- Skip the gold/joven tequilas unless you enjoy headaches and regret.
- Consider your flavor profile. Blanco brings bright, crisp vibes while reposado adds a hint of warmth and complexity.
Now let's get to the good stuff—the seven tequilas that make our mixes sing.
The Magnificent Seven: Best Tequilas for Batchwell Margaritas
1. Espolòn Blanco ($25)
Perfect for: Our Classic Margarita Mix when you want maximum bang for your buck
This is the tequila that proves you don't need to drop serious cash for serious quality. Espolòn brings bold, peppery character with hints of tropical fruit that perfectly complements the balanced citrus in our Classic Mix. At around $25, it's the overachiever of the tequila world—always showing up and showing off without emptying your wallet.
Flavor notes: Bright agave, pepper, hint of tropical fruit Why it works: Clean finish that lets the lime-forward notes in our mix shine through
Shop Espolòn Blanco on Total Wine
2. 2. Olmeca Altos Plata ($36)
Perfect for: Any Batchwell mix when you're making rounds for friends
Altos is the workhorse tequila that bartenders actually drink when nobody's looking. Made with traditional tahona-crushed agave, it brings authentic flavor at a price that makes it perfect for those "everyone's coming over" moments. The slight sweetness balances beautifully with the tangy lime in our mixes.
Flavor notes: Cooked agave, citrus zest, sweet herbs Why it works: Smoothness that belies its price point, standing up nicely to our bold flavors
Shop Olmeca Altos Plata on Curiada
3. El Tesoro Blanco ($65)
Perfect for: When you want to fully experience our Classic, Spicy, or Skinny mix in all their glory
Not all blancos are created equal, and El Tesoro proves it. This traditionally-made beauty lets you taste what tequila is supposed to taste like—vibrant, complex, and unapologetically agave-forward. Paired with our mixes, it creates a margarita experience that makes you stop mid-sip and wonder why you ever drank anything else.
Flavor notes: Pepper, mineral, citrus, touch of apple and pear Why it works: The complexity adds depth to our mixes without competing with them
Shop El Tesoro Blanco on Sip Tequila
4. Siete Leguas Blanco ($56)
Perfect for: Spicy Margarita Mix when you want to impress tequila snobs
The tequila aficionado's choice that somehow stays under the radar. Siete Leguas delivers a complex, herbaceous profile that dances perfectly with the heat in our Spicy Margarita Mix. When someone claims they "don't like margaritas," this is the combo that changes their mind.
Flavor notes: Cooked agave, spearmint and mint, slight sweet notes of wood, caramel and vanilla Why it works: That perfect balance of brightness and complexity that elevates the spice
Shop Siete Leguas Blanco on Blackwell’s Spirits & Wines
5. Fortaleza Reposado ($200)
Perfect for: Classic Margarita Mix when you're ready to level up
When you want to sip slow and appreciate what's in your glass, this is your move. Aged just enough to add vanilla and caramel notes without losing the agave soul, Fortaleza Reposado turns our Classic Mix into something borderline transcendent. Yes, it's pricier, but some nights deserve the upgrade.
Flavor notes: Vanilla, butter, citrus, mild oak Why it works: Adds a subtle richness that transforms our mix from excellent to extraordinary
Shop Fortaleza Reposado on Whisky & Whiskey
6. Tapatio Blanco ($50)
Perfect for: When you want a no-frills, absolutely perfect margarita
Tapatio flies under the radar but delivers pure, unfiltered tequila satisfaction. Made the old-school way by the legendary Carlos Camarena, this blanco brings intense agave character that creates a margarita with serious depth. Pair it with either of our mixes for a drink that needs no explanation, just appreciation.
Flavor notes: Intense agave, white pepper, mint, residual sweetness of white chocolate Why it works: Its bold personality amplifies the quality ingredients in our mixes
Shop Tapatio Blanco on Total Wine
7. Cascahuin Tahona Blanco ($99)
Perfect for: When you deserve something special and are using our mixes for a celebration
The bottle your tequila-loving friends will notice on your bar. Distilled using the ancient tahona stone wheel method, Cascahuin delivers extraordinary complexity that transforms a simple margarita into a contemplative drinking experience. When paired with our mixes, you'll wonder why you ever wasted time with lesser spirits.
Flavor notes: Roasted agave, mineral, bright citrus, herbaceous Why it works: Its nuanced complexity creates layers of flavor with our premium mixes
Shop Cascahuin Tahona Blanco on Sip Tequila
What to Watch Out For When Choosing Tequila
Not all tequila is created equal. Here are some red flags to help you avoid wasting your money and ruining a perfectly good batch of Batchwell margaritas:
1. Mixto vs. 100% Agave
Always check that "100% agave" appears on the label. If it's not there, you're looking at a mixto tequila that can contain up to 49% non-agave sugars and additives. These create harsher flavors and more brutal hangovers. The slight savings aren't worth the morning after.
2. Artificially Colored Gold Tequilas
That amber-gold color in an unaged tequila? It's not from careful craftsmanship—it's caramel coloring and additives. These gold/joven tequilas are usually mixtos in disguise, designed to look aged when they're really just dressed up with artificial ingredients. Stick with transparent blancos or properly aged reposados.
3. Plastic Bottles = Hard Pass
We're not saying all expensive tequilas are good (they're not), but we are saying that any tequila sold in a plastic bottle has made its priorities very clear. Quality producers invest in proper glass bottles to protect their product. If the brand cuts corners on packaging, imagine what corners they're cutting on what's inside.
4. Suspiciously Sweet Aromas
If a tequila smells like candy, vanilla extract, or artificial sweetener, put it back. Quality tequila should smell like, well, agave—with earthy, vegetal, and sometimes peppery notes. Anything overly sweet likely contains glycerin or other additives designed to mask poor distillation.
5. Rock-Bottom Pricing
Yes, there are good values in tequila (like Espolòn and Olmeca Altos on our list), but when prices drop below $15-18, you're almost certainly getting something that shouldn't be mixed with our premium margarita mixes. Your taste buds and your tomorrow morning self will thank you for spending those few extra dollars.
How to Mix the Perfect Batchwell Margarita
Now that you've upgraded your tequila game, here's how to make magic happen with our mixes:
1. Start with quality ice – Large, clear cubes melt slower and won't water down your masterpiece.
2. Get the ratio right – For our Classic, Spicy, or Skinny Margarita Mix:
- 1 packet Batchwell Mix
- 1.5 oz quality tequila from our list above
- 3 oz water
- Shake with ice until perfectly chilled
3. Rim half the glass – Because sometimes you want salt, sometimes you don't. Use coarse sea salt or even everyone’s favorite Trader Joe's Chili Lime Seasoning for an extra kick.
4. Garnish thoughtfully – A fresh lime wheel for the Classic, a thin jalapeño slice for the Spicy. Simple, not fussy.
The Bottom Line
A great margarita isn't complicated, but it does require respect for the ingredients. Our Batchwell mixes deliver real flavor without shortcuts, and they deserve a tequila that does the same.
Whether you go for the everyday excellence of Espolòn or the special-occasion splurge of Cascahuin, pairing quality tequila with our premium mixes means you'll never have to fake enjoying your drink again.
Ready to step up your margarita game? Grab our mixers on Amazon and once you've mastered the classic, try out our level-up variations on our Recipes page.
Pro tip: Hosting a tasting party? Get a few different tequilas from our list and let your friends discover their perfect match with our mixes. Just maybe hide the good stuff from that one friend who doesn't appreciate the difference. You know the one.
Batchwell delivers instant craft cocktails with real ingredients and unmatched convenience. Our flavor-packed singles turn ordinary drinks into extraordinary experiences. Get in the mix at webatchwell.com.
